For sale

This one's priced below recent comparable sales, and 27 days on market. Here's everything I've got — ask me anything about it.

Orillia · Orillia

423 Mary Street

Detached

MLS® #S13662954

Listed for$565,00027 days on market

4 bed 2 bath 7 parking 1100-1500 sq ft~$435/sq ft

27 days on market
2 schools within 1 km
Transit stop ~1.1 km

Free · about 10 seconds

Is $565,000 a fair price?

Our read: it’s priced below recent comparable sales — based on 75 sales nearby. Sign in free to see exactly how far below it is, plus the full range comparable homes sold in.

No obligation · unsubscribe anytime

Measured against 75 recent comparable sales nearby — sign in free to see the range they sold in (boards require a verified email · VOW rules).

Est. all-in monthly~$2,926/momortgage + property tax + maintenance · 20% down · example rate (compounded semi-annually) — the math on the list price, not a quote or what you can afford. For real rates, Alex can connect you with a mortgage pro.

On the map

Loading map…

This home below comps above in lineOpen full map →

2 schools within ~1 km · nearest transit stop ~1.12 km

Property information

What house buyers ask first

Lot size: 34 × 107.98 ft
Square footage: 1100-1500 sq ft
Age: ~51-99 years old
Property tax: $3,568 / yr
Parking: 7 spaces · Attached
Basement: Finished, Full, Crawl Space

Property summary

Property type: Detached
Style: Sidesplit
Approx. age: 51-99 years
Lot size: 34 × 107.98 ft
Parking: 7 spaces · Attached
Heating: Forced Air
Air conditioning: Central Air
Basement: Finished, Full, Crawl Space
Kitchens: 1
Exterior: Aluminum Siding, Brick
Property tax: $3,568 / yr
MLS®: S13662954

Room dimensions

Primary Bedroom

Second3.84 × 3.04 m

Bedroom 4

Lower3.58 × 2.63 m

Kitchen

Main2.78 × 3.56 m

Dining Room

Main2.86 × 2.71 m

Bedroom 3

Second3.18 × 3.04 m

Recreation

Basement6.13 × 5.56 m

Bedroom 2

Second3.84 × 2.77 m

Living Room

Main3.54 × 4.72 m

As stated by the MLS®, nothing inferred.

Nearby homes for sale

Below-comps first · all nearby homes shown, not just the good-value ones.

Detached

$575,000

Below recent sales

636 Mississaga Street W

3 bed · 2 bath·1100-1500 sq ft·7 parking

Orillia

Listed 24 days ago · Parker Coulter Realty Brokerage Inc.

Listing states: renovated

Detached

$674,900

Below recent sales

10 Andrea Crescent

4 bed · 2 bath·1500-2000 sq ft·3 parking

Orillia

Listed 21 days ago · Century 21 B.J. Roth Realty Ltd.

Detached

$719,900

Below recent sales

377 MARY Street

3+1 bed · 4 bath·1500-2000 sq ft·5 parking

Orillia

Listed 10 days ago · Century 21 B.J. Roth Realty Ltd.

Detached

$739,900

Below recent sales

37 Laurentian Lane

4 bed · 3 bath·2000-2500 sq ft·2 parking

Orillia

Listed 98 days ago · Century 21 B.J. Roth Realty Ltd.

Detached

$789,999

Below recent sales

92 Quinn Avenue

3+1 bed · 2 bath·2000-2500 sq ft·4 parking

Orillia

Listed 25 days ago · Real Broker Ontario Ltd.

Detached

$725,000

Below recent sales

55 Laurentian Lane

3+1 bed · 4 bath·1500-2000 sq ft·6 parking

Orillia

Listed 45 days ago · RE/MAX Right Move

The numbers that matter

Property tax: $3,568/yr
Est. all-in: ~$2,926/mo

Nearby rental listings are facts. Whether it works as a rental is a chat with Alex — not a number I’ll put on it.

Schools

Schools near this home, closest first by straight-line distance. These are factual locations — AskEmma doesn’t rate or rank schools.

Harriett Todd Public SchoolPublic · Elementary & Secondary · Simcoe County DSB0.8 km
Twin Lakes Secondary SchoolPublic · Secondary · Simcoe County DSB0.9 km

Locations: Open Database of Educational Facilities (ODEF), Statistics Canada v2.1 (2022) · Open Government Licence – Canada. School locations as of 2022 — confirm current catchment and enrolment with the school board. For official provincial results, check EQAO.

Getting around

Public transit near this home, by straight-line distance. Factual locations from OpenStreetMap — not walking time, and not a rating.

University Ave @ Diana DrNearest transit · Bus stop~1.1 km

Locations: OpenStreetMap public-transit stops, © OpenStreetMap contributors · Open Database Licence (ODbL). Stop locations from OpenStreetMap — confirm current routes and service with the transit agency.

Community — Orillia

$600KMedian sold

39Median days on market

96.7%Sale-to-list

Median sold price · Orillia1-yr -6% · 3-yr —

Source: TRREB sold data via Repliers · all property types

Description & details

CORNER LOT SIDESPLIT WITH BIG-TICKET UPDATES, A BACKYARD BUNKIE, FINISHED BASEMENT & OVERSIZED GARAGE! 423 Mary Street starts strong where buyers tend to look hardest, with a newer steel roof, updated windows, newer A/C, furnace (2025), water heater (2025), plus an oversized single garage and a 10x10 bunkie or shed for bikes, tools, hobby gear or the extras that never seem to fit inside. Set on a corner lot in a mature Orillia neighbourhood, this sidesplit has an updated front porch, ample driveway parking and a backyard with room for gardens, pets, play or future plans. The main level offers an open-concept living and dining area warmed by a gas fireplace, along with a practical kitchen featuring a newer dishwasher. The upper level keeps all three bedrooms together with a 4-piece bathroom, while the lower level adds a flexible fourth bedroom or office and a 3-piece bathroom. The finished basement extends the living space with a spacious rec room and convenient laundry featuring a new washer and dryer (2025). Additional highlights include central vac and an owned water heater, giving buyers one less rental item to factor in. Multiple parks, Harriett Todd P.S. and Twin Lakes S.S. are within walking distance, with the Orillia Rec Centre, Hwy 12, shopping, amenities and Orillia Soldiers' Memorial Hospital just a quick drive away. This #HomeToStay takes the sting out of homeownership by checking off the big-ticket essentials, leaving you free to focus on the fun stuff, like styling the open-concept main floor or deciding what that backyard bonus space could become.

The data only goes so far — condition, light and layout are worth seeing in person, with a home inspection, before you commit.

Listed by RE/MAX HALLMARK PEGGY HILL GROUP REALTY. Showings via AskEmma by Alex Goodman, Sales Representative, RE/MAX Your Community Realty, Brokerage.